Navigating the Bitcoin ETF Hype: A Critical Analysis
Published on January 20, 2024
Author : Greg Hauw, Founder & CEO, Ohanae, Inc

Cryptocurrency enthusiasts and investors alike are abuzz with the recent approval of 11 new Bitcoin Exchange-Traded Funds ("ETF") by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission ("SEC"). However, before succumbing to the fear of missing out ("FOMO") and rushing into the cryptocurrency market through these new investment vehicles, it's crucial to dissect the implications and examine whether these funds align with prudent investment strategies.

Bitcoin ETFs: The Hype and Reality

The SEC's green light for Bitcoin ETFs is not a proclamation of Bitcoin's newfound legitimacy. Instead, it merely introduces a new set of investment options within the ETF universe. While major financial institutions like BlackRock, Fidelity, and others have jumped on the Bitcoin bandwagon, it doesn't automatically make the cryptocurrency a suitable core holding for every investor.

Jeff Sommer, in his recent New York Times column, aptly points out that FOMO is not a rational basis for investment decisions. Bitcoin remains speculative, challenging to categorize, and lacks a clear economic function. The SEC's approval doesn't elevate Bitcoin to the status of a mainstream asset class; it simply broadens the array of legal investment choices, joining the ranks of narrowly focused ETFs that cater to specific investment themes or strategies.

The SEC's Caution and Investor Responsibility

Amid the excitement surrounding Bitcoin ETFs, the SEC issued a stern warning against succumbing to FOMO. Lori Schock, the director of the SEC's Office of Investor Education and Advocacy, emphasized that just because others are entering this space doesn't mean investors should blindly follow suit. This echoes a recurring theme from regulatory bodies urging caution and due diligence in the volatile world of digital assets.

While the new ETFs may attract significant attention, particularly from institutional investors, ordinary individuals planning for retirement, homeownership, or education should approach Bitcoin investments with prudence. The cryptocurrency's unpredictable future and evolving definition demand a careful approach.

Bitcoin's Place in a Diversified Portfolio

Bitcoin advocates often compare it to gold, suggesting it serves as a modern hedge against uncertainty. However, Jeff Sommer challenges this comparison. Gold, with its historical significance, commercial uses, and cultural roles, differs significantly from Bitcoin. The notion of Bitcoin as an essential component of a well-balanced, long-term investment portfolio is dubious at best.

Research indicates that even a small allocation to Bitcoin can significantly increase the risk profile of a conservative stock-bond portfolio. Investors should be wary of the potential impact on their overall portfolio stability, especially considering Bitcoin's volatility. While blockchain technology holds promise, Bitcoin's current status as a speculative asset raises concerns about its suitability for conservative, long-term investors.

Unveiling Hidden Exposure: The Coinbase Connection

Surprisingly, even without the new Bitcoin ETFs, many investors may already have exposure to Bitcoin through indirect channels. The majority of these ETFs rely on Coinbase for critical functions, and the largest holders of Coinbase are mutual funds and ETFs managed by industry giants such as Vanguard, BlackRock, State Street, and Fidelity.

In this interconnected financial ecosystem, investors may unknowingly hold shares in companies with exposure to Bitcoin, such as MicroStrategy and firms involved in Bitcoin mining. The unintended exposure arises from the broad holdings of index funds, showcasing the complexity of navigating the cryptocurrency landscape within traditional investment vehicles.

Vanguard's Principled Stand

Vanguard, a prominent player in the index fund space, has taken a principled stand against directly offering Bitcoin ETFs or other crypto-related products. Karyn Baldwin, a Vanguard spokeswoman, reiterated the company's focus on traditional asset classes like equities, bonds, and cash as the building blocks of a well-balanced, long-term investment portfolio.

This deliberate approach aligns with the skepticism surrounding Bitcoin's classification as a legitimate asset class. While publicly traded companies engaged in Bitcoin-related activities may find their way into index funds, it doesn't necessarily validate Bitcoin as a foundational investment instrument.

Conclusion: Investing with Prudence

The SEC's approval of Bitcoin ETFs marks a notable development in the cryptocurrency landscape, but it doesn't inherently transform Bitcoin into a mainstream asset. As investors grapple with the allure of these new funds, it's essential to distinguish between speculative hype and sound, long-term investment principles.

Bitcoin's role in a diversified portfolio remains a subject of debate, with cautionary tales echoing from recent market events. Investors, especially those with conservative financial goals, must weigh the potential rewards against the inherent risks. The allure of Bitcoin, akin to other speculative endeavors, might offer excitement and short-term gains, but it demands a discerning eye and a clear understanding of the broader investment landscape.

In the end, the SEC's actions don't alter the fundamental nature of Bitcoin. It remains a high-risk, high-reward asset, and investors should approach it with the same caution applied to any speculative investment. The current hype surrounding Bitcoin ETFs should prompt investors to reflect on their long-term financial objectives, risk tolerance, and the role of cryptocurrency within a diversified investment strategy.

NY Times Article:

Jeff Sommer: Crypto Funds Have Arrived. But Who Needs Them?


An offering statement regarding this offering has been filed with the SEC.  The SEC has qualified that offering statement, which only means that the company may make sales of the securities described by the offering statement.  It does not mean that the SEC has approved, passed upon the merits or passed upon the accuracy or completeness of the information in the offering statement.  The offering circular that is part of that offering statement is at  You should read the offering circular before making any investment.

Ohanae Securities LLC is a subsidiary of Ohanae, Inc. and member of FINRA/SIPC. Additional information about Ohanae Securities LLC can be found on BrokerCheck. Ohanae Securities LLC is in discussions with FINRA about exploring the expansion of business lines for the broker/dealer.  Any statements regarding abilities of Ohanae Securities LLC are subject to FINRA approval and there are no guarantees FINRA will approve the broker/dealer’s expansion.

Ohanae Securities is seeking approval to be a special purpose broker-dealer that is performing the full set of broker-dealer functions with respect to digital asset securities – including maintaining custody of these assets – in a manner that addresses the unique attributes of digital asset securities and minimizes risk to investors and other market participants. If approved, Ohanae Securities will limit its business to digital asset securities to isolate risk and having policies and procedures to, among other things, assess a given digital asset security’s distributed ledger technology and protect the private keys necessary to transfer the digital asset security.