Cryptocurrency, once envisioned as a renegade financial sector, is now at a crossroads as federal judges weigh whether digital currencies should adhere to the same regulations as stocks and bonds. In a recent New York Times article by Matthew Goldstein and David Yaffe-Bellany, the authors explore the implications of the ongoing legal battles between the crypto industry and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). These lawsuits, particularly against major crypto firms like Coinbase and Binance, could significantly shape the future of the multitrillion-dollar crypto industry in the United States.
The Howey Test Dilemma
The collision between the crypto industry and a 1946 Supreme Court decision, known as the Howey Test, has intensified over the last 18 months. The SEC has argued that cryptocurrencies are essentially securities, akin to traditional stocks and bonds, and therefore should be subject to the same regulations. The crypto industry, on the other hand, contends that Wall Street trading laws are not applicable to digital currencies. The outcome of this legal battle is pivotal, as it could determine whether the crypto industry can continue thriving in the United States.
An Existential Issue for Crypto
Legal experts, including Hilary Allen, a professor at American University specializing in financial regulation, see these court battles as "an existential issue for crypto." The SEC's enforcement lawsuits, claiming that crypto companies are operating as unregulated securities businesses, have sparked a vigorous defense from the industry. Early court victories left the matter unsettled, but recent hearings in cases against Coinbase and Binance are expected to be more decisive, with preliminary rulings anticipated in the coming weeks. The potential for these cases to reach the Supreme Court adds further significance to their outcomes.
SEC's Blueprint and Crypto's Origins
The SEC's regulatory approach to crypto is grounded in the Howey Test, which determines whether a financial product qualifies as a security. Gary Gensler, the SEC chair, argues that most digital currencies fall under this classification, as investors hope for price increases driven by the companies issuing the currencies. The crypto industry sees this approach as overly broad and insists on a formal contract between the seller of a digital coin and an investor for it to constitute a securities transaction.
The origins of crypto date back to 2008 when Bitcoin's software was created, envisioning a decentralized alternative to traditional finance. However, as the industry matured, companies resembling traditional finance firms emerged, leading to aggressive marketing of cryptocurrencies. The government viewed this emerging sector as an unregulated version of Wall Street, resulting in a surge of enforcement actions by the SEC in 2022.
The Ripple Case and Legal Precedents
The legal landscape for crypto faced a turning point in the SEC's lawsuit against Ripple. A federal judge ruled that Ripple's cryptocurrency did not qualify as a security when bought and sold on public exchanges by amateur investors. However, a subsequent case supported the SEC's view that different cryptocurrencies qualified as securities, creating a split that raises the stakes for the cases against Coinbase and Binance.
The Coinbase and Binance Hearings
Recent hearings in the Coinbase and Binance cases delved into the applicability of the Howey Test to digital currencies. Lawyers for Coinbase argued against the SEC's attempt to stretch the test's intent, claiming that cryptocurrencies without a clear contractual agreement are similar to other collectibles that can rise in value over time. The judges overseeing these cases, particularly Judge Katherine Polk Failla in the Coinbase case, expressed concerns about the SEC's potential overreach.
In the Binance case, Judge Amy Berman Jackson was more skeptical of comparing digital coins to collectible toys but pressed government lawyers to clarify the boundaries of their argument. The outcomes of these cases will significantly impact the legal standing of various digital assets, potentially leading to broad rulings that affect the entire crypto industry.
The Future: Optimism Amidst Challenges
As the legal battles unfold, the crypto industry remains optimistic, especially after a recent victory when the SEC approved a new Bitcoin investment product for trading on Wall Street. The industry's optimism is rooted in the belief that these legal challenges can be overcome, allowing for continued growth and innovation.
In conclusion, the crypto industry's clash with the SEC and the Howey Test represents a pivotal moment that could shape the future of finance in the United States. The outcomes of the cases against Coinbase and Binance will determine whether cryptocurrencies can integrate more deeply into the American financial system or face restrictions that could stifle their growth. The intersection of innovation, regulation, and legal precedent will undoubtedly define the next chapter for the crypto industry.
NY Times Article:
An offering statement regarding this offering has been filed with the SEC. The SEC has qualified that offering statement, which only means that the company may make sales of the securities described by the offering statement. It does not mean that the SEC has approved, passed upon the merits or passed upon the accuracy or completeness of the information in the offering statement. The offering circular that is part of that offering statement is at https://vdr.ohanae.com/projects/ohanae. You should read the offering circular before making any investment.
Ohanae Securities LLC is a subsidiary of Ohanae, Inc. and member of FINRA/SIPC. Additional information about Ohanae Securities LLC can be found on BrokerCheck. Ohanae Securities LLC is in discussions with FINRA about exploring the expansion of business lines for the broker/dealer. Any statements regarding abilities of Ohanae Securities LLC are subject to FINRA approval and there are no guarantees FINRA will approve the broker/dealer’s expansion.
Ohanae Securities is seeking approval to be a special purpose broker-dealer that is performing the full set of broker-dealer functions with respect to digital asset securities – including maintaining custody of these assets – in a manner that addresses the unique attributes of digital asset securities and minimizes risk to investors and other market participants. If approved, Ohanae Securities will limit its business to digital asset securities to isolate risk and having policies and procedures to, among other things, assess a given digital asset security’s distributed ledger technology and protect the private keys necessary to transfer the digital asset security.